Wealth structuring in the Isle of Man allows high-net-worth individuals and business owners to create a financial legacy while potentially mitigating the constraints imposed by forced heirship laws.
As a common law jurisdiction, the Island provides trust and foundation options that allow individuals to retain greater control over their estates while ensuring compliance with legal requirements in their home countries.
Forced heirship, prevalent in many civil law jurisdictions including France, Spain, Italy, and several Middle Eastern countries, mandates that a portion of a deceased person’s estate be distributed to specific heirs, typically children or spouses, regardless of the testator’s wishes. These rules, designed to prevent disinheritance, often create significant challenges for estate planning, business succession, and intergenerational wealth transfer.
Advantages of forced heirship principles:
1. Protects family members: Ensures children and spouses receive financial support after the death of a relation.
2. Prevents disinheritance: Stops individuals from unfairly disinheriting close relatives.
3. Reduces estate disputes: Clear legal guidelines can prevent conflicts between heirs.
4. Promotes stability: Helps maintain security by ensuring property and wealth remain within families.
Disadvantages of forced heirship principles:
1. Limits testamentary freedom: The deceased cannot distribute their assets entirely as they wish.
2. Challenges for commerce: Business owners may struggle to pass control of a company to a chosen successor if forced heirship rules divide shares among multiple heirs.
3. Encourages asset structuring: Some individuals seek ways to avoid forced heirship laws, leading to complex and costly legal arrangements.
4. Potential financial burdens: Forced division of assets may require heirs to sell property or businesses to settle inheritance claims.
The practice of high-net-worth individuals (HNWIs) from civil law jurisdictions establishing trusts and foundations in common law jurisdictions to avoid forced heirship issues has become common place as they seek greater flexibility and freedom in terms of estate planning.
Originally part of Coopers & Lybrand, which later became PricewaterhouseCoopers, Abacus has a 40-year history of providing technical expertise and outstanding customer service. Our clients trust us to look after their interests – they value the attention to detail, time and skills of our experienced and qualified team.
No action should be taken on the basis of this note, nor should it be construed as amounting to tax, legal or VAT advice. Suitable, specific and professional advice should always be obtained in respect on any particular issue.
